Fear Your Turkey. Photo: Justin Sullivan, Getty Images
Sure, we like to pretend that Thanksgiving's a magical time when family and friends sit down together in the spirit of joy and harmony, expressing only the warmest feelings of friendship and caring over a deliciously-prepared turkey dinner ... but we know that's only one side of a complex tradition made up of cooking disasters, shaky truces, and general family dysfunction.
Oh yes, Thanksgiving has a dark side. There's a lot riding on that turkey dinner ... and countless Thanksgiving get-togethers around the country are precariously balanced on the edge of a deep, dark chasm. One false move, one careless retort, or one momentary lapse in fire safety can send the entire celebration spiraling into the depths of a Turkey Day inferno more awkward than you can possibly imagine.
Here are a few cautionary tales that show just what can happen when the stuffing hits the fan:
The Turkey That Wouldn't Fly: I was hosting a Thanksgiving barbecue in San Francisco (we can do that in this climate). The grill was knocked over by a guest who had more than their share of champagne, and the turkey rolled off of the patio, and fell 4 stories to the street below. This was all about 1/2 hour before we were going to eat. I could have prevented this disaster by simply moving the grill farther away from the patio's edge, and serving less champagne. -- Retromarin, San Francisco, CA
Pass the Fruit Salad: One year, when we were living in LA, we invited our trainer (who was of course an actor) to join us at Thanksgiving. He neglected to tell us until he was at the groaning table that he had recently decided to become a "Fructarian" which meant he was eating only fruit. While we all (tried) to chow down, he ate a single pear and talked relentlessly about the benefits of eating only fruit. He also mentioned that there were people who were "breath-arians" and that was his ultimate aspiration. Needless to say, it was challenging to enjoy the meal. And that was his last invite to our dinners! -- Beth Colt, Woods Hole, MA
Green Intentions: My boyfriend and I decided to host some friends for our first attempt at preparing Thanksgiving dinner. We reserved a hormone-free, free-range, raw turkey from the spendy new organic market downtown. We didn't own a car, so Brian picked it up after work the night before Thanksgiving, strapping it with a bungee cord to the rack on the back of his bicycle. It was dark, and pouring rain (it does that in San Diego every once in a while)when he rounded a corner going full speed in rush hour traffic. The 20+ pound raw turkey failed to position itself correctly through the turn, and Brian lost control on the slick pavement. Brian, the turkey and bike slid along the pavement for a few yards, but luckily weren't hit by a car. The bike wheel was too bent to roll, so he arrived home with bike and turkey in the back of a cab, soaking wet and looking pathetic. We had to scrub all the asphalt and gravel out of the turkey before cooking it, and one side of the turkey still had severe road rash. Brian cleaned-up a little better. Our friends enjoyed the story, even if the turkey was pretty sad-looking. -- Amy Rowland, San Diego
Blame it on the Cat: The first year I spent thanksgiving with my new in-laws, we were enjoying conversation while waiting for dinner to cook when the house filled with the most horrible smell you can imagine. My mother in law explained that she'd spilled onions on a burner. The house was aired out, and we enjoyed a lovely meal. Years later, after my mother in law had gotten to know me better, she admitted that the smell had actually been a result of her very ill-behaved cat peeing on one of the burners ... and she'd instructed my father in law to not touch that burner ... and he'd forgotten. -- Margaret Crites
Turkey en Flambé: This year we were running late because I had forgotten a special bottle of wine I wanted to share and we'd gone back home to get it. Dinner was supposed to be served at 4:00 and we finally arrived at 3:30. As we walked down the path to their front door, we were greeted by my sister in law yelling, "Gang way - watch out - coming through" and out of the front door she ran with a pot of heavily smoking artichokes. Little did we know what was in store. As we walked in the kitchen, we noticed on the table a completely uncooked totally raw - turkey. (Remember dinner was supposed to be ready in a half an hour?) "Oh don't worry," they said, "we're barbecuing the turkey and it only takes 45 minutes." Except the barbecue hadn't been started yet.
It seems they were just getting to that when they discovered that the briquettes were wet. So rather than going to the store and getting new ones they decided that they had a solution to getting those wet briquettes to ignite -- gasoline! So, just imagine, if you will, a wooden porch with overhanging pine trees. Yeah. After a dose of gasoline, they were right -- the briquettes did light -- shooting three-foot high flames onto the eves of the wooden house. So they put the lid on the Weber and proceeded to wrap the turkey in aluminum foil. "Don't worry, this is how we had planned on cooking it anyway."
Finally as it was getting dark, they were ready to put the turkey on the grill. Quickly they opened the lid. The column of flame shot up anew and they literally threw the turkey on the grill and slammed the lid down. After a few minutes we saw seriously angry flames shooting out of every air hole in the barbecue. Some were leaking out between the top and bottom of the Weber. The fat in the turkey had reached flash point and it was burning out of control. About 30 minutes (and several glasses of wine) later, it was decided that the turkey was probably done cooking and we should probably take it off the grill. A roof high column of flame shot up as they took off the lid. OK, so how do we get the turkey off the grill with all those flames? Using a fireplace poker, the turkey was pushed of the grill where it landed on the wooden deck, still burning furiously. The fat of the turkey and the foil were one as it kept right on burning.
By now there was talk of calling the fire department. But rather than do that, it was decided that someone needed to "put the turkey (fire) out." Of course, using a fire extinguisher would wreck the turkey (like it wasn't ruined already?) so my father-in-law and my nephews grabbed the first thing at hand -- bathroom sized dixie cups -- and began to "spoosh" the flames out. After a few minutes (and a bit more wine) it was finally out. Now, I don't know who decided it was still edible -- but as was family tradition my father-in-law carved and served that turkey - crispy on the outside and raw on the inside -- and we ate stuffing and burnt artichokes while we enjoyed taking pictures of the inedible bird. -- Karen Frank, Pleasant Hill, CA
Mike Licht 11-24-2009 @ 2:07AM
You gotta deep-fry that turkey the Real Guy Way.
See:
notionscapital.wordpress.com/2009/11/24/turkey-torching-tips-for-guys/
Reply
Khrystal 11-24-2009 @ 8:14AM
Wow, I'm glad our Thanksgivings are simple except when we went to my aunt's house and my brother accidentally broke the screen front door, came right of the hinges. :( Man, she fussed about that forever.
Reply
jbjg24m 11-24-2009 @ 8:27AM
these damn spammers !
Reply
Michelle in TN 11-24-2009 @ 9:43AM
My entire family went to my mom's for Thanksgiving 1 year. The black lab was getting excited as she could smell that the turkey was done. To keep her out of the way while we were carving & eating our turkey, she was put outside. From our Thanksgiving feast, we looked up from the table and out back we saw our beloved dog, Shadow, enjoying an entire cooked turkey for herself in the back yard!!! It was obvious that she found a "cooling turkey" on a deck or a smoking turkey and was able to get away with it. We felt awful as we knew there was a family out there somewhere without a turkey for Thanksgiving. Years later, we can laugh about it now!
Reply
bellagrlxitalia 11-24-2009 @ 2:42PM
LMMFAO that is hilarrrrious!
John 11-24-2009 @ 9:55AM
I cooked a turkey (with indirect heat) on my Weber grill last Christmas, along with one done the conventional way. Both turned out well, but my guests enjoyed the turkey done on the Weber over the oven cooked turkey. Partially due to the fact that I had a Jamaican Jerk rub on the turkey on the grill but also because of the way it cooks on the grill. It had a bit of a smokey flavor from wood chips and combined with the rub it was killer!!!! If you grill a turkey, do it on a Weber grill!!
Reply
Pizzt 11-24-2009 @ 12:31PM
omg your Turkey sounds really good with the rub! I'm leaving my crazy family behind this year and coming to join you! =P
Lee 11-24-2009 @ 10:25AM
Never cook a turkey that has been in the freezer a long time. A hotel gave all us employees a turkey every year and they began piling up in my freezer. Unluckily, I decided to use the turkey left in our freezer for a year, the only Thanksgiving my husband's mother visited us. It was totally inedible after cooking -- dry and tasteless -- and she was left wondering what kind of cook her daughter-in-law was.
Reply
Pud 11-24-2009 @ 2:25PM
inject the turkey with a liquid marinade and cook it in a cooking bag, it will always be moist and tasty.
Melindannah 11-24-2009 @ 10:25AM
How is it that we remember the crap memories so vividly yet the good ones are far and few between? I dunno, but there is some enjoyment reading about your crap memories without having to live it out myself.
Happy Thanksgiving everyone. May you have more enjoyable memories to share next year.
Reply
Ellen 11-24-2009 @ 10:34AM
I loved Karen Franks story! Thanks for a good laugh! Happy Thanksgiving!
Reply
Jay 11-24-2009 @ 10:47AM
If you go to someone's house for Thanksgiving,,and there frying a turkey,,,,and you hear the words "YA'LL WATCH THIS",,,,,Run like hell!!! LOL
Reply
don 11-24-2009 @ 11:00AM
I planned on cooking a duck on a grill, after friends arrived and many cocktails later i put the duck on the grill which was outside of our condo. The flames from the grill were about 8 ft high when i opened the grill. I managed to stand there and pour beer on the duck and move it around and eventually cooked it ok. This was after dark. However the next day the people in the condo could not figure out what killed the large bushes around and the tree above the grill. I acted amazed also.
Reply
Trowgo 11-24-2009 @ 11:02AM
Karen Franks story was the funniset I've heard. I will admit I cheat with my Turkey, I buy a butterball smoked fully cooked one, fool proof, plus I have so many sides I'm working on during the day, it just makes sense. My family likes the smoked turkey better. my only opps is that marshmellows have a small window between browned and burnt on the sweet potaotes.
Reply
bajapescadero 11-24-2009 @ 11:05AM
One year, my Brother and I decided to "Pit BBQ" a turkey, after some tequila we dug a pit and started a fire, later after more tequila we buried the turkey on the coals. 4 hours and more tequila later, we dug up the turkey. It was raw..took it to the wives who put it in the oven, more tequila, we ate very late I think!?
Reply
sak0324 11-24-2009 @ 11:09AM
Deep frying turkeys is one of, if not the most, dangerous ways to cool a turkey. Every year you hear about somebody burning their house down because they go in a hurry and tried to skip reading the directions, which are quite convuluted I must say.
Take you time and roast your turkey. It'll look better than one of those shrivelled up fried turkeys and your family wiill love it!
Reply
Dan 12-01-2009 @ 7:47PM
If you know how to read and follow directions, and not cook it on the wooden deck, a fryed turkey is the best.
It keeps the guys out of house, who usually aren't helping anyway.
teresa 11-24-2009 @ 11:34AM
IDIOTS! Use an oven for god sakies.
Reply
Chris 11-24-2009 @ 12:00PM
The Turkey had been in the oven the prescribed amount of time and my Aunt ask my overly celebratory Uncle to turn off the oven and she would get the festivities going in about 5 minutes. Moments later we all heard the scream that came with an varied number of expletives from the kitchen. It seem good ole Uncle Ed had turn the dial to self-clean mode and the oven was locked for the next 4 hours on inferno mode. Burgers on the barbie. YEP!
Reply
sadiemae1214 11-24-2009 @ 11:52AM
Thanksgiving? Yes, that was the very same holiday that I discovered my Beagle knew how to open the refrigerator door.
Reply